Utilizador:InProgress/Parallels - Histórico de revisões

BenMcGuire: /* Proposed Methodology and Criteria in Dealing with Grunder's Parallels */

2010-06-15T18:18:17Z

Proposed Methodology and Criteria in Dealing with Grunder's Parallels

← Revisão anterior		Revisão das 18h18min de 15 de junho de 2010
Linha 6:		Linha 6:

	== Proposed Methodology and Criteria in Dealing with Grunder's Parallels ==		== Proposed Methodology and Criteria in Dealing with Grunder's Parallels ==

			=== Classification of Parallels ===

			Grunder's proposed parallels can be broken down into several basic categories. Some of them are more or less self-explanatory. Others require a bit more information. The proposed system (and this is a tentative proposal at this point) is to break them down in the following fashion.

			A: Parallel texts which are offered as some kind of theme which is generally stated (i.e. Hebrew origins of the American Indians) without providing actual material for comparison. While it probably could be useful to discuss these issues, this is an approach to the parallels themselves, and where Grunder doesn't provide specific text for comparison, this study will generally exclude that example from consideration.

			B: Parallels which seem to be merely accidental or coincidence. This category covers parallels which exist but which don't actually seem to be able to infer some kind of connection for a variety of reasons. In general, these parallels will fail at multiple criteria for identifying valid parallels.

			C: Parallels which exist but which are pervasive in the environment. This category covers parallels that can reflect only a cultural or linguistic influence. In general, these are not specific enough to claim any kind of reliance or even common sources between texts because of pervasiveness in the environment or other concerns. No sense of direction of movement is discernible, and the texts themselves are unrelated except for the notion of coming from a common environment.

			D: Parallels which exist and for which a common source or earlier tradition can be reasonably identified. For these parallels, the notion is that not only is there a valid parallel, but the parallel is such that a real tradition can be seen behind the texts. While a pedigree of the parallels may not be able to be determined, the relationship between the texts can be discussed in meaningful ways.

			E: Parallels which exist and for which a pedigree of sorts can be determined. That is how the texts are related can be fairly closely identified (even if the one is not reliant on the other).

			F: Parallels which exist in which one can be closely tied to the other in a deterministic fashion and the parallel is directional (i.e. one text relies on the other).

			=== Criteria for Evaluating Parallels ===

			in progress

	== Commentary on Grunder's Introduction ==		== Commentary on Grunder's Introduction ==

BenMcGuire em 18h02min de 15 de junho de 2010

2010-06-15T18:02:29Z

← Revisão anterior		Revisão das 18h02min de 15 de junho de 2010
Linha 3:		Linha 3:
	{{nw}}		{{nw}}

	~~Note that you can sign comments or submissions by adding three tilde characters like this: <nowiki>~~~</nowiki> at~~ the ~~end~~ of ~~your posts. The software will add your name. If you want to add the time you made the comment, add 4 such characters.~~		== Comments on the Work as a Whole ==

			== Proposed Methodology and Criteria in Dealing with Grunder's Parallels ==

			== Commentary on Grunder's Introduction ==

			== Commentary on Grunder's Technical Introduction ==

			== Classification of Parallels ==

			== Discussion of Individual Parallels ==

GregSmith em 17h22min de 15 de junho de 2010

2010-06-15T17:22:34Z

← Revisão anterior		Revisão das 17h22min de 15 de junho de 2010
Linha 3:		Linha 3:
	{{nw}}		{{nw}}

	Note that you can sign comments or submissions by adding three tilde characters like this: <nowiki>~~~</nowiki> at the end of your posts. The software will add your name. If you want to add the time you made the comment, add 4 such characters. ~~[[User:GregSmith\|Greg Smith]] 17:22, 15 June 2010 (UTC)~~		Note that you can sign comments or submissions by adding three tilde characters like this: <nowiki>~~~</nowiki> at the end of your posts. The software will add your name. If you want to add the time you made the comment, add 4 such characters.

GregSmith em 17h22min de 15 de junho de 2010

2010-06-15T17:22:20Z

← Revisão anterior		Revisão das 17h22min de 15 de junho de 2010
Linha 3:		Linha 3:
	{{nw}}		{{nw}}

	Note that you can sign comments or submissions by adding three tilde characters like this: <nowiki>~~~</nowiki> at the end of your posts. The software will add your name. If you want to add the time you made the comment, add 4 such characters. ~~[[User:GregSmith\|Greg Smith]]~~ [[User:GregSmith\|Greg Smith]] 17:22, 15 June 2010 (UTC)		Note that you can sign comments or submissions by adding three tilde characters like this: <nowiki>~~~</nowiki> at the end of your posts. The software will add your name. If you want to add the time you made the comment, add 4 such characters. [[User:GregSmith\|Greg Smith]] 17:22, 15 June 2010 (UTC)

GregSmith em 17h22min de 15 de junho de 2010

2010-06-15T17:22:05Z

← Revisão anterior		Revisão das 17h22min de 15 de junho de 2010
Linha 3:		Linha 3:
	{{nw}}		{{nw}}

	Note that you can sign comments or submissions by adding ~~four~~ tilde characters like this: <nowiki>~~~~</nowiki> at the end of your posts. The software will add your name ~~and~~ the time you made the comment ~~automatically~~. 17:21, 15 June 2010 (UTC)~~		Note that you can sign comments or submissions by adding three tilde characters like this: <nowiki>~~~</nowiki> at the end of your posts. The software will add your name. If you want to add the time you made the comment, add 4 such characters. [[User:GregSmith\|Greg Smith]] [[User:GregSmith\|Greg Smith]] 17:22, 15 June 2010 (UTC)

GregSmith em 17h21min de 15 de junho de 2010

2010-06-15T17:21:29Z

← Revisão anterior		Revisão das 17h21min de 15 de junho de 2010
Linha 3:		Linha 3:
	{{nw}}		{{nw}}

	Note that you can sign comments or submissions by adding four tilde characters like this: <nowiki>~~~~</nowiki> at the end of your posts. The software will add your name and the time you made the comment automatically. 17:21, 15 June 2010 (UTC)		Note that you can sign comments or submissions by adding four tilde characters like this: <nowiki>~~~~</nowiki> at the end of your posts. The software will add your name and the time you made the comment automatically. 17:21, 15 June 2010 (UTC)~~

GregSmith em 17h21min de 15 de junho de 2010

2010-06-15T17:21:13Z

← Revisão anterior		Revisão das 17h21min de 15 de junho de 2010
Linha 3:		Linha 3:
	{{nw}}		{{nw}}

	Note that you can sign comments or submissions by adding four tilde characters like this: <nowiki>~~~~</nowiki> at the end of your posts. The software will add your name and the time you made the comment automatically. ~~[[User~~:~~GregSmith\|Greg Smith]]~~		Note that you can sign comments or submissions by adding four tilde characters like this: <nowiki>~~~~</nowiki> at the end of your posts. The software will add your name and the time you made the comment automatically. 17:21, 15 June 2010 (UTC)

GregSmith em 17h20min de 15 de junho de 2010

2010-06-15T17:20:56Z

← Revisão anterior		Revisão das 17h20min de 15 de junho de 2010
Linha 3:		Linha 3:
	{{nw}}		{{nw}}

	Note that you can sign comments or submissions by adding four tilde characters like this: <nowiki>~~~~</nowiki> at the end of your posts. The software will add your name and the time you made the comment automatically. 17:~~20, 15 June 2010 (UTC)~~		Note that you can sign comments or submissions by adding four tilde characters like this: <nowiki>~~~~</nowiki> at the end of your posts. The software will add your name and the time you made the comment automatically. [[User:GregSmith\|Greg Smith]]

GregSmith em 17h20min de 15 de junho de 2010

2010-06-15T17:20:43Z

← Revisão anterior		Revisão das 17h20min de 15 de junho de 2010
Linha 3:		Linha 3:
	{{nw}}		{{nw}}

	Note that you can sign comments or submissions by adding four tilde characters like this: <nowiki>~~~~</nowiki> at the end of your posts. The software will add your name and the time you made the comment automatically.		Note that you can sign comments or submissions by adding four tilde characters like this: <nowiki>~~~~</nowiki> at the end of your posts. The software will add your name and the time you made the comment automatically. 17:20, 15 June 2010 (UTC)

GregSmith: Created page with 'Notes and methodology for Ben McGuire's parallels project: {{nw}} Note that you can sign comments or submissions by adding four tilde characters like this:
2010-06-15T17:20:29Z

Created page with 'Notes and methodology for Ben McGuire's parallels project: {{nw}} Note that you can sign comments or submissions by adding four tilde characters like this: <nowiki></nowiki…'

Página nova
Notes and methodology for Ben McGuire's parallels project:

{{nw}}

Note that you can sign comments or submissions by adding four tilde characters like this: <nowiki></nowiki> at the end of your posts. The software will add your name and the time you made the comment automatically.